Home » News » TFAS Debate: Is Edward Snowden A Patriot Or Traitor?

TFAS Debate: Is Edward Snowden A Patriot Or Traitor?

//////////////////////

On July 28, TFAS hosted a powerhouse debate about former NSA contractor Edward Snowden: with one side applauding Snowden as a patriot, and the other side calling him traitor with a capital T.

 

Robert Turner, associate director of the University of Virginia Center for National Security Law, claimed that Snowden is a traitor, while Bruce Fein, chairman of the American Freedom Agenda and civil liberties attorney claimed that Snowden is a patriot who invoked democracy to function.

They presented opposing views to questions such as: Was the collection of telephonic metadata by the NSA legal? Have there been negative outcomes for society or the security community since the documents leaked? Have there been any positive reforms? What is the constitutional interpretation of the Fourth Amendment as it applies to this issue?

Robert Turner of the University of Virginia explains his points about why Snowden should be considered a traitor.

Student Leeanna Matarazzo (IEIA 14) said she doesn’t believe the issue is black and white, but that she and her fellow TFAS students became more informed to better formulate their own opinions after hearing remarks from Turner and Fein.

“I think this is a really powerful topic, specifically for students interested in working in the intelligence community like myself,” Matarazzo said. “It’s a moral dilemma that needs to be considered, and there were definitely a lot of emotions involved in the debate. I have emotional ties to the topic as a native New Yorker.”

Student Ryan Sun (IEIA 14) said he came in with the persuasion that Snowden is more of a patriot, but Turner made very compelling arguments for why that may not be true. Sun was also impressed with the professional experience and knowledge of both Fein and Turner.

TFAS President Roger Ream (ICPES 76) (left) speaks with Bruce Fein and debate moderator Gary Armstrong (ICPES 84) (right) following the debate.

“These men have great expertise because they’ve had so much experience on the front lines of foreign policy and intelligence,” Sun said. “We really benefitted from hearing their insight because they have experienced these issues in real life, not just from an academic perspective.”

Turner said that NSA collection programs are constitutional and have been approved by the courts. He maintained that the government collects data to match against databases, similar to law enforcements’ database of fingerprints used in criminal investigations, or license plate numbers collected by the Department of Motor Vehicles. The government, he said, searches or collects data to prevent another Sept. 11, and that the tragedy may never have happened if the security community hadn’t been constrained by policies promoting transparency.

Bruce Fein answers a TFAS student’s question at the conclusion of the debate. Numerous students lined up to further engage with Fein and Turner after the debate.

Fein said that Snowden’s revelation about the NSA’s collection of telephonic metadata enabled litigation and thus invoked democracy to function. Fein classifies Snowden as a patriot because he “saved his country from the government.” Fein advocated that the general public should know more about what the government is doing so that they can make more informed decisions when exercising the right to vote.

Both Turner and Fein agreed on two points: that the NSA has been collecting telephonic metadata, and that the fourth amendment is the standard to evaluate the NSA’s actions.

TFAS alumnus John Sweda (ICPES 97) attended the event and said that while he is still conflicted about whether Snowden is a patriot or traitor, he is much more informed.

“Events like this help students realize there are two sides to every issue. There is no one way to view things, and students can see that other people view the world in a different way than they do,” Sweda said. “Some people have different opinions and we have to be able to work with that the best we can as Americans.”

 

 

1047
post

Recent Posts

//////////////////////

Liberty + Leadership News: December 2

Read the latest TFAS alumni and supporter updates in this week's Liberty + Leadership News.

29th Annual TFAS Journalism Awards Dinner Honors Courage and Prestige in Journalism

The Fund for American Studies (TFAS) was joined by donors, sponsors, alumni and friends at the 29th Annual TFAS Journalism Awards Dinner on Nov. 15, 2022 in New York. TFAS and guests celebrated the next generation of top-notch journalists, while honoring…

Liberty + Leadership Podcast – Ibrahim Al-Marashi on Leadership Through Passion

This week, another exceptional TFAS alumnus joins us on the Liberty + Leadership Podcast: Ibrahim Al-Marashi - graduate of the 2001 TFAS class, professor of Middle East History at California State University San Marcos (CSUSM), professor at IE University in…